DEEP DIVE

As a woman with PCOS, you’ve probably heard this at least once:
“Your labs look normal.”

And yet you’re still exhausted.
Still gaining weight easily.
Still breaking out.
Still losing hair.
Still crashing at 3PM.

The problem isn’t always that testing wasn’t done.
It’s that lab results are often interpreted too narrowly.

Most lab reports are based on reference ranges — not optimal ranges. A reference range simply reflects what is statistically common in the population. It does not mean hormonally optimal. And when it comes to PCOS, context matters more than a green check mark next to a number.

Let’s break down what this means in real terms.

This is one of the most commonly missed early warning signs in PCOS.

If your fasting glucose is normal but your fasting insulin is elevated, your body is working harder than it should to keep blood sugar controlled. Glucose looks fine because insulin is compensating behind the scenes.

That compensation is insulin resistance.

Over time, chronically elevated insulin can contribute to abdominal weight gain, acne, irregular cycles, increased androgens, and fatigue — even before glucose levels become abnormal. Waiting until glucose rises means waiting until the system is already strained.

If fasting insulin is high (even with normal glucose), that’s early metabolic stress — not “everything is fine.”

Fasting labs only tell you what’s happening at rest. They don’t show how your body responds to food.

Many women with PCOS have normal fasting glucose but exaggerated post-meal glucose and insulin spikes. That’s where symptoms often live.

Post-meal testing (sometimes called a glucose tolerance test with insulin measurements) can reveal how efficiently your body clears glucose after eating. If insulin rises dramatically and stays elevated longer than expected, it confirms insulin resistance — even when fasting labs appear normal.

If you experience intense fatigue after meals, cravings shortly after eating, or the 3PM crash, post-meal glucose dynamics may be playing a role.

Asking your doctor about post-meal glucose or insulin testing can provide insight that fasting labs alone cannot.

PCOS is often associated with elevated androgens, but interpreting these labs requires nuance.

Total testosterone, free testosterone, DHEA-S, and SHBG (sex hormone-binding globulin) all matter. A woman may have total testosterone within range but elevated free testosterone due to low SHBG. Since SHBG binds excess hormones, lower levels mean more active circulating androgens — even if total testosterone looks “normal.”

Symptoms like acne, facial hair growth, scalp hair thinning, and irregular cycles may reflect androgen activity that isn’t obvious at first glance.

DHEA-S, which is produced primarily by the adrenal glands, can indicate whether stress-related adrenal activation is contributing to androgen excess. Elevated DHEA-S alongside high stress and sleep disruption tells a different story than ovarian-driven testosterone elevation.

Numbers alone don’t tell the whole story. The relationship between markers matters.

Thyroid dysfunction often overlaps with PCOS symptoms. Fatigue, hair thinning, weight changes, and irregular cycles can all be influenced by thyroid function.

Most doctors screen with TSH alone. While TSH is useful, it doesn’t always capture thyroid resistance or conversion issues.

Your thyroid produces mostly T4 (inactive form), which must be converted into T3 (active form) to influence metabolism. Stress, inflammation, and insulin resistance can impair this conversion.

A TSH within range does not always mean optimal thyroid function. Looking at free T3, free T4, and thyroid antibodies can provide a more complete picture, especially if symptoms persist despite “normal” TSH.

When metabolism feels sluggish but labs appear acceptable, deeper thyroid evaluation may be warranted.

You don’t need to challenge your doctor aggressively. You can ask collaborative questions.

Instead of saying, “These labs are wrong,” you might say, “Can we look at insulin alongside glucose to understand the full picture?” Or, “Would it make sense to evaluate post-meal glucose if my fasting labs are normal but symptoms persist?”

When discussing androgens, you might ask, “Can we review SHBG and free testosterone together?” For thyroid concerns, “Would it be reasonable to assess T3 conversion given my ongoing symptoms?”

Framing your questions around patterns rather than single numbers shifts the conversation from confrontation to partnership.

PCOS is not a single-number condition. It is a pattern-based condition involving insulin signaling, inflammation, androgen balance, and stress physiology.

When labs are interpreted in isolation, the pattern is missed. When they’re interpreted together, they tell a story.

If you still feel off despite “normal” labs, that doesn’t mean you’re imagining symptoms. It means the interpretation may need more context.

And understanding that context is one of the most powerful ways you can advocate for your health.

You live in your body every day.
Your experience is data too. 🩸

Why PCOS Queens? I want to save you the energy and time in researching and instead give you the shortcut to managing PCOS. I want to help you avoid feeling self-conscious and thinking you have to accept how things are. I want to help you overcome the worst of your symptoms, feel empowered and discover your inner strength. I want to hand you the keys to take back control of your life.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the product links featured in this newsletter may be affiliate links. This means PCOS Queens may earn a small commission (at no extra cost to you) if you choose to make a purchase. We only share products we genuinely believe may be helpful for our community.

Medical Disclaimer: Every woman is unique, and this information is provided for educational purposes only. I share summarized research data and personal experience, but this should not be considered medical advice. Always consult your doctor or healthcare provider for guidance on your specific health needs.